Difference between revisions of "Talk:Gina Rocco"
m (you know your tired when it takes 3 attempts to get anything right) |
|||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
At what point should releases be entered in this database? From 2006? I will add Moonlight Potato... but am unsure on the rest given they were likely mostly before her arrival here. | At what point should releases be entered in this database? From 2006? I will add Moonlight Potato... but am unsure on the rest given they were likely mostly before her arrival here. | ||
-thedugganaut | -thedugganaut | ||
| + | <br> | ||
| + | yep add moonlight potato, it was partially recorded and mastered in Hamilton. - Geoff | ||
| + | |||
| + | I think if she's based in Htown now, then list whatever she's released ever I reckon. I mean, Hamilton bands/artists that move out still get listed. -dan. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Yeah, I dont know... I kind of get the feeling that if a band/bandmember was here and then moves on, they still carry with them the influence of Hamilton. Whereas if a band/bandmember comes here and has recordings beforehand, those earlier recordings dont have the same influence. If that makes sense. Im not really fussed either way though, and I am happy to list all recordings in these cases, as long as there is some kind of caveat in the individual discographies noting which recordings were done prior to arrival in Hamilton. Im still not 100% sure where to draw the line on Gina Rocco's discography though, but I guess given Geoff says Moonlight Potato was partially recorded here, everything prior probably wasnt? | ||
| + | -thedugganaut | ||
| + | |||
| + | yes, I think that's right. Her stuff didn't have any hamilton connection until moonlight potato. - I think that if an artist is included, we have an interest in completeness at that point, whether or not the individual elements of the complete entry fulfil the criteria by themselves. - Geoff | ||
Latest revision as of 12:27, 6 May 2007
Info on Gina Rocco's releases are on the Powertool records page: http://www.powertoolrecords.co.nz/ginarocco.htm
At what point should releases be entered in this database? From 2006? I will add Moonlight Potato... but am unsure on the rest given they were likely mostly before her arrival here.
-thedugganaut
yep add moonlight potato, it was partially recorded and mastered in Hamilton. - Geoff
I think if she's based in Htown now, then list whatever she's released ever I reckon. I mean, Hamilton bands/artists that move out still get listed. -dan.
Yeah, I dont know... I kind of get the feeling that if a band/bandmember was here and then moves on, they still carry with them the influence of Hamilton. Whereas if a band/bandmember comes here and has recordings beforehand, those earlier recordings dont have the same influence. If that makes sense. Im not really fussed either way though, and I am happy to list all recordings in these cases, as long as there is some kind of caveat in the individual discographies noting which recordings were done prior to arrival in Hamilton. Im still not 100% sure where to draw the line on Gina Rocco's discography though, but I guess given Geoff says Moonlight Potato was partially recorded here, everything prior probably wasnt? -thedugganaut
yes, I think that's right. Her stuff didn't have any hamilton connection until moonlight potato. - I think that if an artist is included, we have an interest in completeness at that point, whether or not the individual elements of the complete entry fulfil the criteria by themselves. - Geoff
